Ancient Philosophy

80-250
Summer I, 2006

Teaser Trailer

1. Have you ever admired Greek fashion?

2. If the tortoise is given a head start, can Achilles ever overtake him in a race?

3. What could Plato be daydreaming about here?

4. Have you ever wondered if Socrates could beat Superman in a fight?

Find answers to these and other burning questions this summer in Ancient Philosophy.

 

Your Instructor

Name: David Gray, Graduate Student Extraordinaire

Office: Baker Hall 143

Work Phone: 412-268-8148

Email: degray@andrew.cmu.edu

 

Course Description

This course provides a broad survey of Ancient Greek philosophy from the pre-Socratics, through Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, to the later Hellenistic writers. Through careful study of primary texts we will explore some of the historical and intellectual movements that led up to and culminated in the flourishing and downfall of Periclean Athens. A study of Socrates (as represented in Plato's early dialogues) will lead to an in-depth reading of Plato's Phaedo, Meno, and sections of the Republic. We will then explore Aristotle's systematization of philosophy through selections from the Categories, Physics, Metaphysics, De Anima, and the Nicomachean Ethics. This course provides a strong foundation in the history of philosophy, and the history of western moral, political, metaphysical, epistemological, and psychological thought more generally.

 

Important Handouts

Syllabus
Features of the Ancient Greek Revolution
Parmenides’ Arguments for What-Is
Zeno of Elea’s Argument Against Plurality
Democritus’ Skepticism
Gorgias: On Nature or What-Is-Not
Principles and Definitions from Plato’s Euthyphro
Socrates’ Fundamental Principles from Plato’s Crito
Plato’s Meno

 

Schedule

Date
Topic
Readings
May 22

Introductions

None

May 23 The Homeric World View

Homer, Iliad and Odyssey (Handout)

Hesiod, Theogony (Handout)

Irwin, "Homer" from Classical Thought (CT), pp. 6-19

Adkins, "Plato" from Ethics in the History of Western Philosophy, pp. 5-11 (Handout)

May 24 The Milesian Monists

Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes, Fragments from Baird and Kaufmann, Ancient Philosophy (AP), pp. 6-10

Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes, Additional Fragments (Handout)

Irwin, "The Naturalist Outlook", "Nature as Matter", and "Conceptions of Nature" from (CT), pp. 20-23

May 25 Pythagoras and Xenophanes

Pythagoras and Xenophanes, Fragments from (AP), pp. 11-15

Pythagoras and Xenophanes, Additional Fragments (Handout)

May 26 Heraclitus

Heraclitus, Fragments from (AP), pp. 15-18

Heraclitus, Additional Fragments (Handout)

Irwin, "Change and Stability", "Nature and History", "Nature and Medicine", "The Problems of Method", "General Laws", "Reason and Argument", "Ethics", and "The Gods" from (CT), pp. 23-42

     
May 29

No Class!

Memorial Day - Woo Hoo!
May 30 The Eleatics

Parmenides, Zeno of Elea, and Melissus, Fragments (AP), pp. 19-30

Parmenides and Zeno of Elea, Additional Fragments (Handout)

Irwin, "Parmenides on Speaking and Thinking", "Parmenides Against Change", "Zeno Against Plurality", and "Parmenides and Zeno: Sense and Reason" from Classical Philosophy (Handout)

May 31 The Eleatic Dilemma

Reread the Eleatics

June 1 The Pluralists

Empedocles, Anaxagoras, Leucippus, and Democritus, Fragments from (AP), pp. 31-42

Empedocles, Anaxagoras, and Leucippus, Additional Fragments (Handout)

Irwin, "Tendencies", "Appearance and Nature", "Nature and Purpose", "Nature and Cosmic Justice" from (CT), pp. 43, 47-52

June 2 The Sophists and Athenian History

Protagoras, Gorgias, and Critias, Fragments (AP), pp. 43-48

Thucydides, excerpts from The History of the Peloponnesian War (Handout)

Irwin, "Tragedy and Naturalism", "Beyond Naturalism", "Naturalism and Human Nature", "Questions About Naturalist History", "Some Effects of Naturalism", "Radical Doubt", "Convention, Truth, and Reality", "Scepticism, Conventionalism, and Morality", "Political Tensions", "The Growth of Political Debate", "Practical Results", and "Unsettled Questions" from (CT), pp. 44-47, 53-67

     
June 5 Intro to Socrates - Euthyphro

Plato, Euthyphro from (AP), pp. 76-88

Irwin, "Morality and Religion" and "The Unity of Morality" from (CT), pp. 75-79

June 6 Apology

Plato, Apology from (AP), pp. 88-105

Irwin, "Socrates' Trial", "Socrates' Defense", and "Socratic Arguments" from (CT), pp. 68-75

June 7 Crito

Plato, Crito from (AP), pp. 105-113

Irwin, "The Problem of Justice" and "Intelligible Misunderstandings of Socrates" from (CT), pp. 79-84

First Paper Handed Out

June 8 Intro to Plato - Meno

Plato, Meno from (AP), pp. 157-171 (70-86c)

Irwin, "Socrates and Plato", "The Theory of Socratic Argument", "Inquiry and Recollection", and "Knowledge and Belief" from (CT), pp. 85-89

June 9 Meno Plato, Meno from (AP), pp. 171-181 (86c-100)
     
June 12 Phaedo

Plato, Phaedo from (AP), pp. 114-129 (57-78a)

Irwin, "The Theory of Socratic Definition", "The Senses", "Questions About the Forms", "Soul and Body", and "The Soul and the Self" from (CT), pp. 90-94, 98-101

June 13 Phaedo

Plato, Phaedo from (AP), pp. 138-150, 154-156 (91c-107c, 115b-118)

First Paper Due

June 14 Republic I Plato, Republic, Book I, pp. 1-31
June 15 Republic II Plato, Republic, Book II, pp.32-59
June 16 Republic III-IV

Plato, Republic, Book III-IV, pp. 88-93, 102-121 (412b-417, 427d-445)

Irwin, "The Problem of Justice", "Reason and Desire", "The Defense of Justice", and "Virtue and Philosophy" from (CT), pp. 101-106

     
June 19 Republic V-VII

Plato, Republic, Book V-VIII, pp.148-156, 180-193 (473c-480, 506d-521b)

Irwin, "The Theory of Socratic Knowledge", "Knowledge, Morals, and Politics", "Knowledge and Freedom", "The Cosmos", and "Misunderstandings of Plato" from (CT), pp. 94-97, 106-117

June 20 Intro to Aristotle - Categories

Aristotle, Categories, from (AP), pp. 315-320

Second Paper Handed Out

June 21 Physics I

Aristotle, Physics, Book I, Chapters 1, 5-9, translated by Hardie and Gaye, pp. 315, 321-338 (Handout)

Irwin, "Aristotle and His Predecessors", "Observation and Experience", "Philosophical Argument", "Nature and Change", and "Form and Matter", from (CT), pp. 118-126

June 22 Physics II

Aristotle, Physics, Book II, Chapters 1-3, 7-9, from (AP), pp. 329-33, 336-340

Irwin, "Causes" and "Nature and Form" from (CT), pp. 126-130

June 23 Metaphysics VII Aristotle, Metaphysics, Book VII, Chapters 1-4, 6, 10-11, 13, 15-17, translated by Ross, pp. 1623-1627, 1628-1629, 1633-1638, 1639-1640, 1641-1644 (Handout)
     
June 26 On the Soul

Aristotle, On the Soul, Excerpts from Books II and III, from (AP), pp. 365-371

Irwin, "Soul and Body" and "Dualism and Materialism" from (CT), pp. 130-132

June 27 Nicomachean Ethics

Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book I and excerpts from Book X, from (AP), pp. 371-385, 436-441

Irwin, "The Human Good" and "Ethics and Self-Sufficiency" from (CT), pp. 133-136, 140-142

June 28 Nicomachean Ethics

Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book II, and excerpts from Books III and IV, from (AP), pp. 385-405

Irwin, "Happiness and Virtue", "Virtue and the Good of Others", and "Ethics and Society" from (CT), pp. 136-140

Second Paper Due

June 29 Nicomachean Ethics

Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book VI, from (AP), pp. 406-418

Irwin, "The Significance of Aristotle" from (CT), pp. 142-144

June 30 Final Exam  
     

 

Course Texts

  • Forest E. Baird and Walter Kaufmann. Philosophy Classics, Vol. I: Ancient Philosophy. Fourth Edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1994.
  • Terence Irwin. Classical Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989.
  • Plato. Republic. Translated by G.M.A Grube and revised by C.D.C. Reeve. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1992.

 

Useful Links

Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy -- http://www.rep.routledge.com/index.html
Sweet online resource! Go here first. There is also a CD-ROM version available from CMU's Hunt Library.

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy -- http://plato.stanford.edu
Another good online encyclopedia for philosophy.


Answers

1. I know I certainly have!

2. Not according to Zeno of Elea.

3. Perhaps about how the novelty of his ridiculously huge Rubric's Cube has worn out.

4. Scholars still debate on who would be superior -- Superman or Socrates -- but as Jeremy Avigad puts it, "I bet Socrates could confuse the hell out of Superman."

 

 

I love Apache! So should you!