Postcard | Reunion | Date | Attended | Place | Hosts |
| 1st | 7/4/1894 | | East of Hartfield, NY | Orrin Raynor |
| 2nd | 8/29/1895 | | Westfield, NY | Melvin Johnson |
| 3rd | 8/11/1896 | | Portland, NY | Fred Coe |
| 4th | 8/26/1897 | | Portland, NY | N D Johnson |
| 5th | 7/04/1898 | | Stockton, NY | F B Taylor |
| 6th | 8/11/1899 | | Stockton, NY | A R Johnson |
| 7th | 8/16/1900 | | Union City, PA | P K Drurey |
| 8th | 8/15/1901 | | Prospect Station, NY | Locke Johnson |
| 9th | 8/21/1902 | | Brocton, NY | Bruce Johnson |
| 10th | 8/20/1903 | | Stockton, NY | Chester Johnson |
| 11th | 8/18/1904 | | Westfield, NY | Melvin Johnson |
| 12th | 1905 | | Waldermeer | Royal Shepard |
| 13th | 1906 | | Celoron, NY | |
| 14th | 8/21/1907 | | Union City, PA | Andrew Johnson |
| 15th | 8/19/1908 | | Union City, PA | Carperter Shepard |
| 16th | 8/18/1909 | | Fredonia, NY | Bruce Johnson |
| 17th | 8/22/1910 | | Brocton, NY | W S Barber |
| 18th | 8/16/1911 | | Westfield, NY | F D Wallace |
| 19th | 8/21/1912 | | Clymer, NY | James Crosscut |
| 20th | 8/20/1913 | 75 | Brocton, NY | Allen T Johnson |
| 21st | 8/19/1914 | | Portland, NY | Chester Johnson |
| 22nd | 8/19/1915 | | Westfield, NY | M F Johnson |
| 23rd | 8/17/1916 | | Union City, PA | E J Hall |
| 24th | 8/16/1917 | | Brocton, NY | Mrs Millie Scrivens |
| 25th | 1918 | | | Forest Johnson |
| 26th | 8/21/1919 | | Brocton, NY | Fred Coe |
| 27th | 8/19/1920 | 65 | Grange Hall, McKane, Erie Co, PA | Mr & Mrs Reed Coburn |
| 28th | 8/11/1921 | | Glenwood Park, Erie, PA | Royal Shepard |
| 29th | 8/7/1922 | | Westfield, NY | Melvin Johnson |
| 30th | 8/15/1923 | | Corry, PA | Calvin Smith |
| 31st | 8/20/1924 | | Westfield, NY | Melvin Johnson |
| 32nd | 8/19/1925 | | Union City, PA | Earle Kimmey |
| 33rd | 8/18/1926 | | Red House | Frank Johnson |
| 34th | 8/17/1927 | | Fredonia, NY | Forest Johnson |
| 35th | 8/8/1928 | | Union City, PA | Perry Johnson |
| 36th | 1929 | | | |
| 37th | 8/27/1930 | | North East, PA | Robert Grimshaw |
| 38th | 8/12/1931 | | Union City, PA | Archie Shepard |
| 39th | 8/10/1932 | | Red House | Frank Johnson |
| 40th | 1933 | | | |
| 41st | 8/8/1934 | | Marvins UC, PA | Perry Johnson |
| 42nd | 8/14/1935 | | Stockton, NY | Elwoods Coe |
| 43rd | 8/12/1936 | | Clymer, NY | S W Wallace |
| 44th | 8/11/1937 | | Ashville, NY | Wm Schutt |
| 45th | 8/10/1938 | | Union City, PA | Percy Burns |
| 46th | 8/9/1939 | | Ottoway Park, Westfield, NY | Earl Saigeon |
| 47th | 8/14/1940 | 125 | Mayville, NY | Loren Spear |
| 48th | 8/13/1941 | | Sinclairville, NY | Forrest Johnson |
| 49th | 8/9/1942 | | North East, PA | Robert Grimshaw |
| 50th | 9/6/1943 | | Sherman, NY (Little America) | Roy Schutt |
| 51st | 1944 | | | |
| 52nd | 1945-1946 | | | |
| 53rd | 8/17/1947 | 79 | Ottoway Park, Westfield, NY | Earl, Melvin, Lovina Saigeon & Francis Johnson |
| 54th | 1948 | | | |
| 55th | 8/28/1949 | | Ottaway Park, Westfield, NY | Earl Saigeon |
| 56th | 8/27/1950 | | Ottaway Park, Westfield, NY | Robert Grimshaw |
| 57th | 1951 | | Ottaway Park, Westfield, NY | |
| 58th | 1952 | | Union City, PA | Howard Johnson |
| 59th | 1953 | 85 | Salamanca, NY | Earl Johnson Family |
| 60th | 8/22/1954 | 75 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Royal Messenger |
| 61st | 1955 | | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Loyal Burns Family |
| 62nd | 8/26/1956 | 100 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Howard Johnson Family |
| 63rd | 8/25/1957 | 100 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Celia Edwards Family |
| 64th | 1958 | | Ottaway Park, Westfield, NY | Marvin Johnson Family |
| 65th | 1959 | 100 | Canadohta Lake, PA | Howard Johnson Family |
| 66th | 8/21/1960 | 117 | Orchard Beach Park, North East, PA | Grimshaw Family |
| 67th | 8/13/1961 | | Ottaway Park, Westfield, NY | Saigeon Family & Myrtle Stouffer |
| 68th | 8/12/1962 | | Canadohta Lake, PA | Mr & Mrs Howard Johnson |
| 69th | 8/4/1963 | 112 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Alice Messenger Family |
| 70th | 8/9/1964 | 125 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Marjorie K, Mr & Mrs Alvin Fish |
| 71st | 8/8/1965 | | | Royal Messenger Family |
| 72nd | 8/14/1966 | | Rte. 97, Union City, PA | Robert Johnson |
| 73rd | 8/13/1967 | 85 | Dewittville, NY | Mr & Mrs Paul Kehe |
| 74th | 8/11/1968 | 66 | Midway Park, Bemus Point, NY | Mr & Mrs Howard Johnson |
| 75th | 8/10/1969 | 80 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Alice Messenger Family |
| 76th | 8/9/1970 | 90 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Leroy Johnson Family |
| 77th | 8/8/1971 | 98 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Loyal Burns Family |
| 78th | 8/20/1972 | 58 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Howard Johnson Family |
| 79th | 7/29/1973 | 62 | Stockton, NY | Coe and Syper Families |
| 80th | 8/11/1974 | 84 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Edwards Family |
| 81st | 8/10/1975 | 86 | | Mr & Mrs Robert Johnson |
| 82nd | 8/22/1976 | 75 | Sinclairville Village Park, NY | Leroy Johnson Family |
| 83rd | 8/7/1977 | 81 | Sinclairville Village Park, NY | Leroy Johnson Family |
| 84th | 8/27/1978 | 76 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Loyal Burns Family |
| 85th | 8/26/1979 | 77 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Edwards Family |
| 86th | 8/17/1980 | 63 | | Angelo and Janet Picciano |
| 87th | 8/9/1981 | 78 | Stone Quarry Rd, Waterford, PA | Alvin Fish Family |
| 88th | 8/8/1982 | 83 | Crowley Park, Salamanca, NY | Robert Terhune Family |
| 89th | 8/21/1983 | 73 | Crowley Park, Salamanca, NY | Robert Terhune, Earl Johnson, & Joyce Siperek |
| 90th | 8/29/1984 | 64 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Angelo Picciano & J Swisher Family |
| 91st | 8/4/1985 | | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Paul Kehe & David Johnson Family |
| 92nd | 8/24/1986 | 61 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Howard Johnson Family |
| 93rd | 8/9/1987 | 66 | Rte. 97, Union City, PA | Robert Johnson Family |
| 94th | 7/3/1988 | 61 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Loyal Burns Family |
| 95th | 8/6/1989 | 66 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Raymond Johnson Family |
| 96th | 8/5/1990 | 65 | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Raymond Johnson Family |
| 97th | 8/11/1991 | 63 | Caflisch Park, Union City, PA | |
| 98th | 8/9/1992 | | Caflisch Park, Union City, PA | Evelyn and Paul Kehe |
| 99th | 8/15/1993 | | Crowley Park, Salamanca, NY | Robert Johnson Family |
| 100th | 8/7/1994 | | Fireman's Grounds, Stockton, NY | 100th Anniversary Committee |
| 101st | 8/27/1995 | | Fireman's Grounds, Stockton, NY | Elaine Palmer, Titus, Warrean, and Gloria Cosgrove |
| 102nd | 8/11/1996 | | Mead Park, Corry, PA | David Johnson Family |
| 103rd | 8/10/1997 | | Waldameer Park, Erie, PA | Alvin Fish, Jr. |
| 104th | 8/9/1998 | | Fireman's Grounds, Stockton, NY | Peggy and Debbie Johnson |
| 105th | 8/8/1999 | | Freeport Yacht Club, North East, PA | Grimshaw Family |
| 106th | 8/13/2000 | 70 | Caflisch Park, Union City, PA | Mr. & Mrs. Alvin Fish Sr. and Mr. & Mrs. Paul Kehe |
| 107th | 8/12/2001 | | Village Green Park, N Kingsville, OH | Al and Helen Cummings |
| 108th | 8/10/2002 | | Caflisch Park, Union City, PA | Diane & Julius Carniewski |
| 109th | 8/9/2003 | | Village Green Park, N Kingsville, OH | Tom and Deb Peters |
| 110th | 8/3/2004 | | Glenwood Park, Erie, PA | Al and Alvin Fish |
| 111th | 8/14/2005 | | Presque Isle State Park, Erie, PA | Rebecka Carullo |
| 112th | 8/13/2006 | | Midway Park, Maple Springs, NY | Evelyn and Paul Kehe |
| 113th | 8/12/2007 | | Presque Isle State Park, Erie, PA | Eleanor Fish |
| 114th | 8/10/2008 | | Midway Park, Maple Springs, NY | Sypers & Titus |
| 115th | 8/9/2009 | | Glenwood Park, Erie, PA | David & Irene Johnson |
| 116th | 8/8/2010 | | Mead Park, Corry, PA | Alvin Fish Jr and Eleanor Fish |
| 117th | 8/14/2011 | | Elgin Community Park, Elgin, PA | Diane Carnewski & Carol Gee |
| 118th | 8/12/2012 | 77 | Cross Roads Farm, Westfield, NY | David Johnson II & Jane Johnson |
| 119th | 8/11/2013 | 71 | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | David Johnson II & Jane Johnson |
| 120th | 8/10/2014 | 59 | Sparrow Pond Campground, Waterford, PA | Eleanor Fish & Alvin Fish Jr. |
| 121st | 8/9/2015 | 76 | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | Mr. & Mrs. Charles Johnson Jr. |
| 122nd | 8/14/2016 | 60 | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | Irene Johnson & David Johnson III |
| 123rd | 8/13/2017 | 68 | Midway Park, Maple Springs, NY | Evelyn Kehe |
| 124th | 8/12/2018 | | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | Stephanie Ryan |
| 125th | 8/11/2019 | 90 | Fireman's Grounds, Stockton, NY | Betty and Lorna Syper |
| 126th | 8/8/2021 | | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | David Johnson III |
| 127th | 8/7/2022 | | VFW Post 264, Corry, PA | David Johnson III |
| 128th | 8/7/2023 | | Caflisch Park, Union City, PA | Family of the late Lesley Bailes |