Psy 416 Reasoning and Problem Solving
Issues in development of cognition
-
What are the capabilities of children at different age levels?
What can children do? What do they start with? What are the processes by
which they achieve their competence?
-
Piaget: Primary principle of development is adaptation to
the environment. Accommodation: modify oneself to fit the environment;
and assimilation: change things in the environment so that they
can be used.
Stages of development--sensory-motor, preoperational
thought (egocentrism, irreversibility, centering), concrete operations
(conservation tasks), formal operations (symbol manipulation); but decalage
is very important, can find examples of the early stages at all ages with
new materials or domains.
-
Actual complexity in Piagetian type problems. E.g. Conservation
of Number. Try to think of how you could get a computer to solve the task.
Setting up an algorithm requires understanding the task. Each group of
objects is a unit. How do you know this? Data seems to show that children
seem to have an innate concept of a pairing method to identify equal cardinality,
but they need to learn how to order and pair the members. When a child
is asked to count a set of objects she is likely to err both on the sequence
of numbers and the ability to know which are counted and which has yet
to be counted.
-
In order to solve some problems children may have to learn
to ignore some obvious information, perceptual size is ignored in favor
of historical continuity (conservation of volume); habitual location is
ignored in favor of most recent location (object permanence), etc. Some
conservation tasks can be thought of as gaining perceptual and cognitive
structuring (learning what goes together, and how different components
are related) followed by the application of particular algorithms to the
newly organized system (conservation of number, balance beam).
-
More complex problems: Each of these requires more complex
algorithms to be solved. Partial algorithms lead to predictable erroneous
solutions. Mixed juice problems as on pp. 306-7. Noelting (1980), Case
(1978) mix juice and water. Keep adding dimensions needed for solving successive
problems. Ages 3.5 to about 10. No clear stages as they move from low level
to mathematical solutions. Different dimensions. Number, blending principle,
quantity.
-
Siegler’s approach is the same. (Balance beam) More dimensions
of the problem can be noticed. Much older children, ages 7 to 17. Here
they had to be able to do basic mechanics--principle of torque, Number,
distance, side, relation between number and force of gravity, Simple machines
and mechanical advantage, all had to be considered.
-
Vygotsky: Zone of Proximal Development emphasizes cultural
differences and the role of teaching, scaffolding supplied by expert, social
precedes individual, complex skills have to be shaped. Luria and cross-cultural
differences in cognition show cultural influences.
-
Evidence of sophisticated cognitive skills in very young
children: E.g. Identify objects, continuity of objects in contour and through
space, movement of objects. Learning common nouns. Naming dolls and boxes.
-
Chi: With the right kind of experience and training, children
can do very sophisticated categorization. Bruner: Children develop the
skill to incorporate more information in a single view so that they can
"notice" disparities among groups.
Summary of developmental stuff. Piaget implies that
his stages introduce us to universal skills that are applied to all domains.
Although there must be some general skills most of us learn that are highly
useful, they are probably more domain specific. There are good data that
suggest that we never actually reach Piaget's formal operations in most
domains, and we have to go through perceptual learning, and concrete operations
when we enter new domains.
We gradually develop competence in different domains.
One real problem is finding the component processes that are necessary
to do any of the tasks. This can include perceptual integration; object
conceptualization, pragmatic uses, causal analyses, physical dynamics,
abstract relations, understanding number, appropriate knowledge of the
elements, learning the relations between the component parts and how to
maneuver between them. One of the very interesting ways to see how many
component processes are involved is to try to write an algorithm to do
the task. Generate a set of efficient procedures to get there!